drill
A2 · German5 min read

Demonstratives and question articles

dieser, welcher, was für ein

what is it?

Demonstrative articles and question articles are words that accompany — or replace — a noun to point at something, ask about a choice, or ask about the nature of something. German has three main items at A2: dieser/dieses/diese ("this / that"), which points to a specific thing; welcher/welches/welche ("which?"), which asks the listener to pick from a known set; and was für ein ("what kind of?"), which asks about the type or quality of something. All three decline to match the gender, number, and case of the noun they relate to. In addition, the stressed definite article (e.g. Der ist gut!) works as a demonstrative pronoun standing alone, and derselbe ("the same") fuses the article and the stem selb- into one word.

when to use it

  • dieser/dieses/diese — use it to point at something near or already mentioned, equivalent to English "this" or "that". It can also stand alone as a pronoun ("Dieser ist gut").

  • welcher/welches/welche — use it when asking someone to identify or choose one item from a set that both speakers already know about. The answer is typically a specific noun or name.

  • was für ein — use it when asking about the kind, type, or quality of something. The set is open; the answer describes a category or characteristic.

  • stressed der/das/die as demonstrative pronoun — use the stressed definite article when you want to point emphatically at something without repeating the noun: Der ist gut! (That one is good!). Common in spoken German.

  • derselbe — use it to say two things are identical, not just similar: denselben Fehler (the same mistake). In informal speech, im selben Haus (in the same house) is also accepted.

  • so ein / solch- — use these to express "such a": so ein schöner Tag (such a beautiful day). Solch- declines like dieser and is more formal.

jener ("that over there") exists but is largely restricted to formal written German. At A2 you do not need to produce it actively.

formation

dieser declines exactly like the definite article, but with the article endings attached directly to the stem dies-. The same pattern applies to welch- and solch-.

casemasculineneuterfeminineplural
nominativedieserdiesesdiesediese
accusativediesendiesesdiesediese
dativediesemdiesemdieserdiesen
genitivediesesdiesesdieserdieser

Replace dies- with welch- to get the full declension of welcher (e.g. nominative masculine welcher, accusative masculine welchen, dative feminine welcher).

was für ein is built from the fixed phrase was für plus the indefinite article ein-, which declines normally. The word für does not assign accusative here — the case of ein- depends on the noun's grammatical role in the sentence. With plural or uncountable nouns, ein is dropped: Was für Bücher liest du?

noun gender / numbernominative formexample
masculinewas für einWas für ein Film ist das?
neuterwas für einWas für ein Auto hast du?
femininewas für eineWas für eine Schule ist das?
pluralwas für (no article)Was für Bücher liest du?

derselbe fuses the definite article with the stem selb- plus an adjective ending. The article part declines as normal; the selb- part takes a weak adjective ending. Key forms: nominative masculine derselbe, accusative masculine denselben, dative with a preposition im selben (contracted, informal).

examples in context

Dieser Käse schmeckt super.
This cheese tastes great.
Masculine nominative: dieser agrees with Käse (der Käse).
Welches Buch liest du gerade?
Which book are you reading right now?
Neuter accusative: welches agrees with Buch (das Buch). The speaker assumes a known set of books.
Was für ein Auto hast du?
What kind of car do you have?
Neuter accusative: ein stays ein (not einen) because Auto is neuter. The case comes from the noun's role as object, not from für.
— Welches Hemd nimmst du? — Das hier.
— Which shirt are you taking? — This one here.
Stressed das acts as a demonstrative pronoun, replacing the noun entirely.
Er macht denselben Fehler.
He makes the same mistake.
Masculine accusative of derselbe: the article part becomes den-, the stem part takes the weak ending -selben.
Das war so ein schöner Tag!
That was such a beautiful day!
so ein + adjective + noun expresses "such a". ein declines normally; here nominative masculine after war.

common pitfalls

  • Leaving dieser or welcher undeclined. Both words must agree with the noun in gender, number, and case. *dieses Käse is wrong because Käse is masculine nominative → dieser Käse. Likewise *welch Buch → welches Buch (neuter accusative).

  • Confusing welch- with was für ein. Use welch- when the set is known and you want the listener to pick one: Welches Buch liest du? (from the books on the table). Use was für ein when you are asking about type or quality and the set is open: Was für ein Buch liest du? (a thriller? a novel?).

  • Treating für in was für ein as a case assigner. The preposition für normally governs accusative, but in was für ein it is part of a fixed phrase and does not control the case. The case of ein- comes from the noun's role: subject → nominative, direct object → accusative, etc. Was für ein Auto hast du? — Auto is neuter, so ein stays ein (not einen), even though the noun is a direct object.

  • Writing derselbe as two separate words. In careful writing, derselbe is one word. *der selbe Fehler is non-standard. The masculine accusative is denselben (not *den selben or *derselben). The contracted form im selben (= in demselben) is acceptable in informal use.

Demonstratives and question articles in German (A2) · drill